Butler, "Sensitive Nervous System", on "response" and "background systems"
Here is a good sample of Butler's clarity on the matter at hand. From P 84-92:
To be continued. Next, MOTOR SYSTEM AS AN OUTPUT SYSTEM.
I would beg to quibble slightly with Butler about the effects of sympathetic shunting in the brain. He says blood flow is increased to the brain. I would want to ask, which parts? My contention is that blood flow likely increases to the parts that decode vision, equilibrium, motor planning, rage etc.. all the non-conscious mechanisms for enhancing escape. I seriously doubt this involves any sort of thinking in the usual sense of the word, in other words, if a tiger is going to bite you, you aren't going to bother to put a finger to your head to ponder in that moment if it is a Siberian tiger or a Sumatran tiger, or work out the evolutionary tree and where they might have diverged, or stop to chat to your child about the difference in a moment of verbal social grooming. Not really. Chances are the danger would strike one mute except for perhaps a howl issuing from some preverbal part of the more non-conscious brain. So my understanding is that blood flow or at least glucose uptake is actually decreased to the frontals in lots of places and increased elsewhere. Aftrer all, the brain is not monolithic, and lots of the planning/escape centres are evolutionarily much older than the "human" bits.
Here is a good sample of Butler's clarity on the matter at hand. From P 84-92:
IMMUNE, ENDOCRINE, MOTOR AND SYMPATHETIC SYSTEMS AS RESPONSE AND BACKGROUND SYSTEMS
INTRODUCTION
The nervous system processes and gives value to any input. Sometimes this value judgement is visibly expressed via the sympathetic (e.g., sweating, redness) or the motor system (spasm, withdrawal, learnt movement patterns). The responses of other systems such as the immune and endocrine systems remain hidden, at least initially, but could be measured. Nervous system response computations are extremely complex, individual and situation specific. They are usually survival driven but often disturbed by novel modern psychosocial demands.
The systems involved often work synergistically. Although considered as response systems, these systems are also closely associated background homeostatic systems, operating at the same time as signalling in the peripheral and central nervous systems.
Systems such as the endocrine, immune and autonomic are foremost protective systems, yet while they can protect and heal, something which requires considerable power, they can also damage, especially in states of maintained stress and pain. Clinical patterns from the activities of these systems are not as obvious as say, peripheral neurogenic pain. Thee is much synergystic activity betweeen systems, and like all pathobiological mechanisms they will always be in action. In extreme states, the systems will become evident, for example the motor system in focal dystonia, the sympathetic nervous system in complex regional pain syndrome and the endocrine and immune system in Cushing's disease and rheumatoid arthritis. Chronic pain probably involves maladaptive responses in all systems.
A useful way to link things together is to look at the integrated actions of the stress response, remembering that pain is probably the ultimate stressor. Stress biology has only recently been associated with the neurobiology of pain (e.g., Gifford 1998; Melzack 1999; Melzack 1999). Such links and use of the clinical consequences are long overdue. Useful general references include Fink (2000), Sapolsky (1994), Lovallo (1997), and Martin (1997).
AUTONOMIC/NEUROENDOCRINE SYSTEM
Pain and stress will activate three key circuits - the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis (HPA), the sympathoadrenal axis (SA) and the sympathetic neural axis. These are the peripheral limbs of the stress system. The central components are located in the brainstem and hypothalamus. These axes are linked to other brain areas with interests in survival such as the amygdala, multiple cortical areas and the motor system. These three circuits will respond to a variety of signalling including blood borne, sensory, limbic and circadian signals. The circuits will also respond to immune mediated inflammatory moloecules such as tumour necrosis factor alpha and the interleukins 1 and 6.
Pain nearly always acts as a stressor. The activities of these stress systems will also be integrated into the overall CNS processing of pain.
THE HYPOTHALAMUS-PITUITARY-ADRENAL AXIS
Paired adrenal glands, perched on top of the kidneys and essential for life are two of the key structures (Fig. 4.5). They have a central medulla and outer cortex. Both areas function in times of stress, but secrete different chemicals; adrenaline and noradrenaline from the medulla (sympathoadrenal axis) and corticosteroids (cortisol) from the cortex. The cortex is part of the HPA axis.
Cortisol secretions are activated by the adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH) secreted into the blood from the anterior pituitary gland. ACTH secretions, matched by cortisol secretions are high in the morning, low in the evening but stimulated by all forms of stress over 24 hours. Forms of stress such as pain, injury, thoughts, feelings, deeds of others, memories and environmental changes are signalled via corticotrophin releasing hormone (CRH) from the hypothalamus to the pituitary gland (Fig 4.5). The actions of CRH are inhibited by blood cortisol levels which are sampled by the hypothalamus. A feedback system is therefore in operation. CRH neurones and noradrenergic neurones innervate and stimulate each other in the brain, thus linking the stress systems (Chrousos 1995).
CORTISOL
It is the adrenal cortex and its secretion cortisol which are particularly critical to life. Almost all tissues of the body have receptors for cortisol, including the brain. Cortisol gets a bad rap as a stress chemical, but it is vital to life. It maintains cardiovascular and metabolic homeostasis, in particular stimulating protein catabolism and glycogen synthesis - vital energy for dealing with emergencies. In addition, cortisol can cross the blood brain barrier and effect brain structures, one result being mood changes including depression. Cortisol can also exert regulatory effects on the inflammatory and immune responses through the inhibition of cytokine action and production. For reviews, see Lovallo (1997), Fink (2000), and Sternberg and Gold (1997).
In an emergency, cortisol shuts down activities not needed for survival and enhances those that are. Hence the inflammatory and immune systems, digestive and reproductive systems are shut down. With the proverbial tiger confrontation, reproduction, digestion, and wound healing are not high priorites - they can wait for later. Energy goes to systems which can help avoid the stress and contribute to survival, such as the cardiovascular system, brain, and muscles, i.e. be smart, think clearly, and perhaps run very fast.
A chronic excess of cortisol as in chronic pain or stress poses problems. Cushing's syndrome (chronic hypercortisolism) is an extremem example. The features include immunosuppression, osteoporosis, cardiovascular disease, depression and insulin resistance (Whitehouse 2000). More subtle cases of tissue degeneration, mood swings, slow tissue healing and susceptability to infection may be noted by clinicians managing patients with chronic pain.
SYMPATHETIC NEURAL AXIS AND SYMPATHETIC ADRENAL AXIS
The HPA axis is closely linked to the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) by links from the hypothalamus to the locus ceruleus, a key sympathetic nervous system control network in the brainstem. The SNS is also mobilized in times of stress, it innervates immune organs as well as nearly every tissue in the body. Stimulation will evoke arousal, fear, and readiness.
The SNS also plays a role in the stress response and body homeostatic function. A well known figure demonstrating the sympathetic nervous system is in figure 4.6. Note that this one is slightly different from most in that it aknowledges that muscles, joints, skin and the connective tissue sheaths of the nervous system have a sympathetic innervation. The sympathetic nervous system output to the entire body iemerges from slinal levels T1 to L3. The paired trunks are continuous, connective tissue sheathed preganglionic structures, and are known to evoke pain if stimulated (Walker and Nulson 1948; Echlin 1949). One preganglionic sympathetic neurone will diverge onto 15 or more postganglionic neurones (Wolf 1941). Its physical health may be of interest to manual therapists (chapter 15). This part of the nervous system is very glandular - noradrenaline can dribble out of numerous varicosities along postganglionic fibres (Chapter 3).
Altough sympathetic responses are ususally widespread (e.g. total limb or body sweating), the sympathetic nervous system has varying layers of control from local organ to the brain (Lovallo and Sollers 2000). Local organ control allows, for example, blood flow adjustments to muscles, another control layer is ganglionic mechanisms which regulate the output of the postganglionic neurones and then the brain and hypothalamus regulate the entire system. The first two respond more to physiological challenges, the brain responds more to psychological stress.
The sympathoadrenal axis is a powerful part of the sympathetic nervous system. Note in figure 4.6 that the adrenal medulla receives a direct sympathetic preganglionic innervation from the spinal cord. This allows secretion of adrenaline and a little noradrenaline directly and rapidly into the bloodstream. This is known as the sympathetic adrenal axis.
ADRENALIN/NORADRENALINE
Mental and physical effects and psychosocial conditions evoke adrenaline and noradrenaline secretions. Mental stress causes more adrenaline secretion whereas physical stress, linked with more physical activity and blood pressure homeostasis evokes more noradrenaline (Lundberg 2000).
Both adrenaline and noradrenaline prepare us for action. They stimulate cardiovascular responses, blood is shunted to the heart, muscles and brain and away from the digestive system and skin. They promote increased levels of glucose and free fatty acids. More oxygen is available, sweating occurs to cool the body and make it slippery. Via its immune organ innervation, these catacholamines can modulate inflammation. Adrealine is immunosuppressive by altering lymphocyte production from the spleen. These are useful secretions for an emergency, but like cortisol, maintained high levels lead to the risk of cardiovascular disease and tissue damage.
Normal or threshold levels of adrenaline do not exist. Levels may double during mild stress such as daily work. Severe stress with emotional demands may cause levels to rise 10 times the resting level for that person. Novel inputs and anticipation markedly raise adrenaline levels (Lunfberg 2000). However an increased level of adrenaline does not necessarily mean pain. While the levels surely contribute, an upregulated sensory system involving inflammation and adrenoreceptors will be necessary for adrenaline and noradrenaline to access the pain system.
SYMPATHETIC NERVOUS SYSTEM AND PAIN
The sympathetic nervous system can contribute to the sensitivity of inflamed tissues and it can also contribute to the sensitivity of damaged nerves. This can be seen spectacularly with increases in pain if adrenaline is injected into patients with nerve injuries such as a neuroma (Chabal et al 1992; Raja et al 1998). However, adrenaline injected into a person with no nerve injury will be painless.
The sympathetic nervous system is essentially a motor system. To cause pain it must somehow activate the afferent system, especially C and A-delta fibres if the CNS is sensitized. Understanding this pain comes back to receptors. Adrenaline itself does not hurt, it needs receptors attached to nocioceptors to contribute to pain or it must contribute to a chemical soup which activates nocioceptors. Therare thus three places where adrenaline may activate the afferent system. These are contributions to inflammatory soup, contributions to and AIGS or influences due to adrenoreceptor upregulation at the DRG. Adrenaline can act as a central excitatory neurotransmitter, thus it may contribute to the magnification of afferent input. There are more details in chapter 3. Review also figure 3.9.
The stress chemicals such as noradrenaline and cortisol could also contribute to input via destructive effects on tissues. Persistent high level bathing by cortisol and catecholamines appears to have a deleterious effect on connective tissues (Oxlund and Manthorpe 1982; Curwin et al. 1988; Eyre 1990). Noradrenaline pathways in the brain are also closely linked to negative emotional states.
THE PARASYMPATHETIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
Often forgotten with the excitement of the sympathetic nervous system is the parasympathetic nervous system. "Flight and fight" has reminded generations of students about the role of the sympathetic nervous system. The catch cry of the parasympathetic nervous system - "rest and digest" was also proposed by Cannon (Kandel et al 1995), and is just as important for students and patients to understand. Usually these two systems balance each other. The parasympathetic nervous system is more operational at rest when it repairs and heals the tissue traumas of the day.
It may be worthwhile telling patients about this healing and helping system, particularly when talking about sleep health and the need for some patients to introduce relaxation as a coping strategy.
INTRODUCTION
The nervous system processes and gives value to any input. Sometimes this value judgement is visibly expressed via the sympathetic (e.g., sweating, redness) or the motor system (spasm, withdrawal, learnt movement patterns). The responses of other systems such as the immune and endocrine systems remain hidden, at least initially, but could be measured. Nervous system response computations are extremely complex, individual and situation specific. They are usually survival driven but often disturbed by novel modern psychosocial demands.
The systems involved often work synergistically. Although considered as response systems, these systems are also closely associated background homeostatic systems, operating at the same time as signalling in the peripheral and central nervous systems.
Systems such as the endocrine, immune and autonomic are foremost protective systems, yet while they can protect and heal, something which requires considerable power, they can also damage, especially in states of maintained stress and pain. Clinical patterns from the activities of these systems are not as obvious as say, peripheral neurogenic pain. Thee is much synergystic activity betweeen systems, and like all pathobiological mechanisms they will always be in action. In extreme states, the systems will become evident, for example the motor system in focal dystonia, the sympathetic nervous system in complex regional pain syndrome and the endocrine and immune system in Cushing's disease and rheumatoid arthritis. Chronic pain probably involves maladaptive responses in all systems.
A useful way to link things together is to look at the integrated actions of the stress response, remembering that pain is probably the ultimate stressor. Stress biology has only recently been associated with the neurobiology of pain (e.g., Gifford 1998; Melzack 1999; Melzack 1999). Such links and use of the clinical consequences are long overdue. Useful general references include Fink (2000), Sapolsky (1994), Lovallo (1997), and Martin (1997).
AUTONOMIC/NEUROENDOCRINE SYSTEM
Pain and stress will activate three key circuits - the hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal axis (HPA), the sympathoadrenal axis (SA) and the sympathetic neural axis. These are the peripheral limbs of the stress system. The central components are located in the brainstem and hypothalamus. These axes are linked to other brain areas with interests in survival such as the amygdala, multiple cortical areas and the motor system. These three circuits will respond to a variety of signalling including blood borne, sensory, limbic and circadian signals. The circuits will also respond to immune mediated inflammatory moloecules such as tumour necrosis factor alpha and the interleukins 1 and 6.
Pain nearly always acts as a stressor. The activities of these stress systems will also be integrated into the overall CNS processing of pain.
THE HYPOTHALAMUS-PITUITARY-ADRENAL AXIS
Paired adrenal glands, perched on top of the kidneys and essential for life are two of the key structures (Fig. 4.5). They have a central medulla and outer cortex. Both areas function in times of stress, but secrete different chemicals; adrenaline and noradrenaline from the medulla (sympathoadrenal axis) and corticosteroids (cortisol) from the cortex. The cortex is part of the HPA axis.
Cortisol secretions are activated by the adrenocorticotrophic hormone (ACTH) secreted into the blood from the anterior pituitary gland. ACTH secretions, matched by cortisol secretions are high in the morning, low in the evening but stimulated by all forms of stress over 24 hours. Forms of stress such as pain, injury, thoughts, feelings, deeds of others, memories and environmental changes are signalled via corticotrophin releasing hormone (CRH) from the hypothalamus to the pituitary gland (Fig 4.5). The actions of CRH are inhibited by blood cortisol levels which are sampled by the hypothalamus. A feedback system is therefore in operation. CRH neurones and noradrenergic neurones innervate and stimulate each other in the brain, thus linking the stress systems (Chrousos 1995).
CORTISOL
It is the adrenal cortex and its secretion cortisol which are particularly critical to life. Almost all tissues of the body have receptors for cortisol, including the brain. Cortisol gets a bad rap as a stress chemical, but it is vital to life. It maintains cardiovascular and metabolic homeostasis, in particular stimulating protein catabolism and glycogen synthesis - vital energy for dealing with emergencies. In addition, cortisol can cross the blood brain barrier and effect brain structures, one result being mood changes including depression. Cortisol can also exert regulatory effects on the inflammatory and immune responses through the inhibition of cytokine action and production. For reviews, see Lovallo (1997), Fink (2000), and Sternberg and Gold (1997).
In an emergency, cortisol shuts down activities not needed for survival and enhances those that are. Hence the inflammatory and immune systems, digestive and reproductive systems are shut down. With the proverbial tiger confrontation, reproduction, digestion, and wound healing are not high priorites - they can wait for later. Energy goes to systems which can help avoid the stress and contribute to survival, such as the cardiovascular system, brain, and muscles, i.e. be smart, think clearly, and perhaps run very fast.
A chronic excess of cortisol as in chronic pain or stress poses problems. Cushing's syndrome (chronic hypercortisolism) is an extremem example. The features include immunosuppression, osteoporosis, cardiovascular disease, depression and insulin resistance (Whitehouse 2000). More subtle cases of tissue degeneration, mood swings, slow tissue healing and susceptability to infection may be noted by clinicians managing patients with chronic pain.
SYMPATHETIC NEURAL AXIS AND SYMPATHETIC ADRENAL AXIS
The HPA axis is closely linked to the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) by links from the hypothalamus to the locus ceruleus, a key sympathetic nervous system control network in the brainstem. The SNS is also mobilized in times of stress, it innervates immune organs as well as nearly every tissue in the body. Stimulation will evoke arousal, fear, and readiness.
The SNS also plays a role in the stress response and body homeostatic function. A well known figure demonstrating the sympathetic nervous system is in figure 4.6. Note that this one is slightly different from most in that it aknowledges that muscles, joints, skin and the connective tissue sheaths of the nervous system have a sympathetic innervation. The sympathetic nervous system output to the entire body iemerges from slinal levels T1 to L3. The paired trunks are continuous, connective tissue sheathed preganglionic structures, and are known to evoke pain if stimulated (Walker and Nulson 1948; Echlin 1949). One preganglionic sympathetic neurone will diverge onto 15 or more postganglionic neurones (Wolf 1941). Its physical health may be of interest to manual therapists (chapter 15). This part of the nervous system is very glandular - noradrenaline can dribble out of numerous varicosities along postganglionic fibres (Chapter 3).
Altough sympathetic responses are ususally widespread (e.g. total limb or body sweating), the sympathetic nervous system has varying layers of control from local organ to the brain (Lovallo and Sollers 2000). Local organ control allows, for example, blood flow adjustments to muscles, another control layer is ganglionic mechanisms which regulate the output of the postganglionic neurones and then the brain and hypothalamus regulate the entire system. The first two respond more to physiological challenges, the brain responds more to psychological stress.
The sympathoadrenal axis is a powerful part of the sympathetic nervous system. Note in figure 4.6 that the adrenal medulla receives a direct sympathetic preganglionic innervation from the spinal cord. This allows secretion of adrenaline and a little noradrenaline directly and rapidly into the bloodstream. This is known as the sympathetic adrenal axis.
ADRENALIN/NORADRENALINE
Mental and physical effects and psychosocial conditions evoke adrenaline and noradrenaline secretions. Mental stress causes more adrenaline secretion whereas physical stress, linked with more physical activity and blood pressure homeostasis evokes more noradrenaline (Lundberg 2000).
Both adrenaline and noradrenaline prepare us for action. They stimulate cardiovascular responses, blood is shunted to the heart, muscles and brain and away from the digestive system and skin. They promote increased levels of glucose and free fatty acids. More oxygen is available, sweating occurs to cool the body and make it slippery. Via its immune organ innervation, these catacholamines can modulate inflammation. Adrealine is immunosuppressive by altering lymphocyte production from the spleen. These are useful secretions for an emergency, but like cortisol, maintained high levels lead to the risk of cardiovascular disease and tissue damage.
Normal or threshold levels of adrenaline do not exist. Levels may double during mild stress such as daily work. Severe stress with emotional demands may cause levels to rise 10 times the resting level for that person. Novel inputs and anticipation markedly raise adrenaline levels (Lunfberg 2000). However an increased level of adrenaline does not necessarily mean pain. While the levels surely contribute, an upregulated sensory system involving inflammation and adrenoreceptors will be necessary for adrenaline and noradrenaline to access the pain system.
SYMPATHETIC NERVOUS SYSTEM AND PAIN
The sympathetic nervous system can contribute to the sensitivity of inflamed tissues and it can also contribute to the sensitivity of damaged nerves. This can be seen spectacularly with increases in pain if adrenaline is injected into patients with nerve injuries such as a neuroma (Chabal et al 1992; Raja et al 1998). However, adrenaline injected into a person with no nerve injury will be painless.
The sympathetic nervous system is essentially a motor system. To cause pain it must somehow activate the afferent system, especially C and A-delta fibres if the CNS is sensitized. Understanding this pain comes back to receptors. Adrenaline itself does not hurt, it needs receptors attached to nocioceptors to contribute to pain or it must contribute to a chemical soup which activates nocioceptors. Therare thus three places where adrenaline may activate the afferent system. These are contributions to inflammatory soup, contributions to and AIGS or influences due to adrenoreceptor upregulation at the DRG. Adrenaline can act as a central excitatory neurotransmitter, thus it may contribute to the magnification of afferent input. There are more details in chapter 3. Review also figure 3.9.
The stress chemicals such as noradrenaline and cortisol could also contribute to input via destructive effects on tissues. Persistent high level bathing by cortisol and catecholamines appears to have a deleterious effect on connective tissues (Oxlund and Manthorpe 1982; Curwin et al. 1988; Eyre 1990). Noradrenaline pathways in the brain are also closely linked to negative emotional states.
THE PARASYMPATHETIC NERVOUS SYSTEM
Often forgotten with the excitement of the sympathetic nervous system is the parasympathetic nervous system. "Flight and fight" has reminded generations of students about the role of the sympathetic nervous system. The catch cry of the parasympathetic nervous system - "rest and digest" was also proposed by Cannon (Kandel et al 1995), and is just as important for students and patients to understand. Usually these two systems balance each other. The parasympathetic nervous system is more operational at rest when it repairs and heals the tissue traumas of the day.
It may be worthwhile telling patients about this healing and helping system, particularly when talking about sleep health and the need for some patients to introduce relaxation as a coping strategy.
I would beg to quibble slightly with Butler about the effects of sympathetic shunting in the brain. He says blood flow is increased to the brain. I would want to ask, which parts? My contention is that blood flow likely increases to the parts that decode vision, equilibrium, motor planning, rage etc.. all the non-conscious mechanisms for enhancing escape. I seriously doubt this involves any sort of thinking in the usual sense of the word, in other words, if a tiger is going to bite you, you aren't going to bother to put a finger to your head to ponder in that moment if it is a Siberian tiger or a Sumatran tiger, or work out the evolutionary tree and where they might have diverged, or stop to chat to your child about the difference in a moment of verbal social grooming. Not really. Chances are the danger would strike one mute except for perhaps a howl issuing from some preverbal part of the more non-conscious brain. So my understanding is that blood flow or at least glucose uptake is actually decreased to the frontals in lots of places and increased elsewhere. Aftrer all, the brain is not monolithic, and lots of the planning/escape centres are evolutionarily much older than the "human" bits.
Comment