PDA

View Full Version : A hands-on (sort of..) success


Diane
16-10-2004, 08:11 AM
Woman, early 40's, professor, just moved to the wet coast from the east, big city hurry/stress sort of feel about her, brand new job teaching this fall in a major university, wanted to do everything just right, getting her place in shape and unpacked, etc...

Low back pain for 17 years, tons of chiro, tons of everything, no help, finally had her flattened, bulged disc out 2 years ago, big disappointment when she still had pain, although at least she could walk(!) which she couldn't before surgery.. some complications including a nicked dura mater and a subsequent second surgery two weeks later, developed meningitis... finally recovered from all that, still pain bad to the point of couldn't really bend over, pain felt like a tight band preventing her moving.

Treated her this way and that way, tried teaching a few exercises which she didn't do because of being so stressed... talked to her a lot about pain, input, output, Melzack etc.. how it wasn't the "disc" anymore if the disc was out.. on and on, told her my analogy of the cart rut, how we could aim to get her cart (the cycling thoughts) out of the rut (that she was someone who had pain) so that the grass could grow in the rut and it would gradually fill in..

She soaked this up over the course of about 4 sessions, got about 40%better, was bending somewhat better, went to a yoga class that was poorly taught and didn't look after herself during it, did too much, tried too hard, whatever... and ended up at square one again. Palpable frustration. Hope dying. I decided to tape her (kinesio tape). One big strip down the back, stopping just short of the scar. Asked her to bend over. Oh no, I don't want to do that, she said. I said, ok, move around...come and sit here, and bend forward with your elbows between your knees. That she could do, no problem. While she was sitting and bending over I taped her on each side of the first piece with thinner strips, in an upward direction. I asked her to stand up, move around, and then to bend over.

She bent all the way over, with no hesitation. She straightened back up with a look of great shock on her face, and burst into tears.. When I asked her if she was OK, and what were the tears about, she answered that there were two reasons, one, all the frustration and confusion for the last several years was pouring out, and second, tears of relief were coming out. Mostly relief, she said. She really couldn't believe that she had just done what she had done. It took her a few more minutes, and a couple more successful bendovers, to feel confident in her new found ability. Right away she asked, can I go jogging? (argh!) I said, why don't you wait awhile longer and let your brain and body get to know each other again first? She left happy, and offered to pull off articles for me I told her about on my lengthy pubmed clipboard of skin proprioceptor research, at the university library! Hurray, a new source that's local.
Diane

nari
16-10-2004, 09:49 AM
Diane

Way to go! A very satisfying outcome, and it should continue.

What do you think the tape does? Perform skin therapy? Proprioception?
Give the feeling of support? All three?


Nari

Diane
16-10-2004, 04:02 PM
I think the tape stretches the skin a bit this or that way, whichever way is desired by the therapist, likely pulling a little on those skin ligaments, maybe providing a bit of longerterm microneurodynamics to cutaneous innervation "tunnels"... I fiddle with it until the patient says something like, there, now I can stand up on my toes/do whatever movement couldn't be done and it doesn't hurt my leg/ whatever body part formerly hurt.

Definitely it supports. It's like wearing a good bra, anywhere on the body. Definitely it changes proprioception. When in place it doesn't bind or limit movement, it provides better access to movement than before. People who have felt "weak" somewhere for months or years, suddenly feel "strong" with a bit of tape applied over their skin. But it's no placebo, because the tape has to be on it the right direction over the right bit to work its charm. And I think changing skin ligaments slightly is the only mechanism that makes sense.

Diane
10-11-2004, 06:03 PM
Thought I'd post an update on this woman. She came to see me yesterday. I asked her how her back was, and she said she'd had some rough patches, and some painful days, but that today was a "good day."

I asked her if she could still bend over, and she said, yes.
I asked her to show me, and she did. No hesitation, all the way over. No pain.

I asked her how long she'd left the tape on, and she said about 5 days. That she had loved the tape.

I asked her why she had made the appointment, and she said, she still couldn't quite believe that her back was better. When she felt stressed, it would hurt. And I explained about the pain in her back, and the pain in her mind were like water following a stream bed, in her case the same well worn cart tracks, because of how deep they had been worn; that it was not a very big deal... that now that she could drive her cart everywhere, she wouldn't be making the ruts any deeper, and that they would eventually fill in.

She agreed, but still wanted me to tape her again because she was facing a five-hour flight over Canada, and back, with emotional choices to be made at the other end, and relational difficulties to sort out. So I obliged!
Diane