PDA

View Full Version : Ataturk


Barrett Dorko
27-12-2005, 02:54 PM
It’s been a quiet week in Cuyahoga Falls…

Early in the twentieth century Mustafa Kamel Ataturk led an remarkable reformation of Turkish government and society, transforming the country from a fragmented, autocratic and often medieval remnant of the Ottoman Empire into a modern democracy. He died in 1938.

Alex knew enough about the location of the cement plant to head in the right direction, but not much more than that. So he looked up the word “cement” in the Arabic dictionary, got behind the wheel of his vehicle by himself and headed across the desert. The only person he met on the way there was Albanian, so this little bit of local language didn’t help much. Still, he found his way.

Patients arrive in my office for a variety of reasons, and seldom is it because their referral source knows anything at all about my eccentric methods. Their expectations are formed by what happened to their neighbor in therapy and that certainly isn’t going to help them understand my thinking or method. I begin each and every time having to find a way toward them as they shift about mentally and physically in response. I think of it as a dance; they’re leading, but they aren’t yet aware of that.

Seated with two Turkish men in a small office at the back of a cement plant in Iraq, Alex might have thought about how different this setting was than any he’d experienced on Christmas Eve before or how the coffee they offered wasn’t Starbuck’s. Instead, he turned his attention to a poster on the wall. To him, it was familiar figure, it was Ataturk, literally, “The Father of Turkey,” and he told his hosts what he knew about this man’s contribution to their lives.

As I spend that first hour with any patient I look about in their life for something we share and make sure they understand that I can relate on some level. I think the more unexpected this is the more likely it will affect them therapeutically. By that I mean they sense more than a generic connection and begin to appreciate the unique nature of my handling-specifically designed to reveal what they possess that they had not fully expressed. Once I get them past their surprise we begin to dance in a new way-and they learn how to lead.

Alex tells me that the Turkish men were very surprised that he knew of their country’s “one hero” (that’s the way they put it) because they’ve met many US soldiers during the past couple of years and not only didn’t they know of Ataturk, they didn’t especially care about him. Of course, I don’t imagine any of these guys had been political science majors at The Ohio State University either. That makes a difference you know.

“I understand you guys sometimes cook wonderful lamb kebobs for the soldiers,” said Alex. “I’ve been sent here to see if you might do that for the men in my unit on Christmas Day.” The men smiled and said, “When do you want us there?”

When all is said and done, good therapy is dependent upon good communication. And so are so many other things.

To see the result of Alex’s conversation, go to http://www.flickr.com/photos/35469288@N00/

Jon Newman
27-12-2005, 08:36 PM
I have to admit my ignorance of Ataturk. I'm taking care of that (at least a little) with plenty of awe for how I could not know about this fellow as well as for what and how he accomplished things. Alex, it looks like you'd ace Michael Feldman's questions in the "Things you should have learned in school" part of his quiz and based on the picture, the world is a better place for your work.

Diane
27-12-2005, 09:01 PM
When all is said and done, good therapy is dependent upon good communication. And so are so many other things. You can say that again..and again..

emad
27-12-2005, 09:17 PM
Hi Barrett and all ;

I understand very well the story you mentioned above , simple because i am living in an Eastern culture , very similar to your story .

I like to evoke a strange point , was not the man begun one ,regardless ,being created or developed ,this last point is not our track ,i mean there was only one language for humanity , i can not understand this language mass along the world from south to north and from east to west .

Good communication and culture understanding is the main pivot point , I think the Americans are usually attacked through the media ,in the middle east , that they do not care /consider for the Eastern culture /tradations there ,any way ,Barret, I do not like at all to speak politically ,espicially in this public sciene, i can prove myself mentioning very late incident to me , i will forced to leave a hospital by the director ,simply because i sit with my colledge /doctors spoke publically and freely expressed my views about certain issues.

Back ,to patients ,pain ,disease ,physio ,,,,,,, yes, communication could be the main way to help the patient .

Regards
Emad

nari
27-12-2005, 10:18 PM
emad,
Sorry to hear you are being forced to leave..obedience to protocols, cultural and personal differences, misunderstandings and misinterpretations can lead to trouble...for someone, whether in the firing line or not. (With respect to communication)

Ataturk is fairly well known in Australia, largely due to our fervently growing passion with Gallipoli. His descendants celebrate with Aussies and some Poms every year on the Peninsula on 25th April; and Turkey is a well-visited place on Aussie travellers' itinerary. There is more interest in the country than, say with Myanmar or New Guinea. In the Capital, (where I live) there is any amount of information on Turkey and its history easily available.
We still suffer from cultural cringes, but the ropes of colonialism are being steadily cut away.

Nari

emad
28-12-2005, 08:59 PM
Nari ;

thank you for your sympathy .
I am not sad at all to leave that Hospital , the Gover will accept to move me the whole week days to my home town , it was a hospital in a near by town ,working there 3 days in the week , all physiotherapists there hate me , becasue i try to chage their physio tradations which stress people there , any way that town is so deep in dark physio practices , they maitain the patient patient to make more consumers , no one ,never ,never ,never stroke patient in that town walk by physios help ,the patient who returns to walking ,only who is given the gift from the God ( as belifers usually say ) .

I am happy to leave there , i was tired .you are not allowed to speak freely in public if you are in different view ,and you know as usual i am in different view .

Happy new year ,Nari , in advance .

Regards
Emad